Editor's Comment

 
Editor's comments are purely those of the editor and do not necessarily reflect the views of the association.
 
As pretty well everyone is aware the four boats have been named. Victoria, Windsor, Cornerbrook and Chicoutimi. These names were selected based on the the criteria of "considering communities that have an association with the Atlantic/Pacific coasts or a major Canadian waterway that were representative of the various regions of Canada. Accordingly the theme of Canadian port cities was selected"

The real story is the submarines were originally going to be named after an eastern, western, southern and northern port, namely Cornerbrook, Victoria, Windsor and Resolute (or Resolute Bay) but for what ever reason the last one was substituted with Chicoutimi.

In fact one of the Canadian Patrol Frigates was going to be called "Victoria" the idea being each provincial capitol would have a frigate named after it. However that would have meant two provinces would have had two ships bearing their cities names, mainly Ontario with HMCS Toronto and HMCS Ottawa and British Columbia with HMCS Victoria and HMCS Vancouver. 

This would leave all other provinces with one ship each bearing one of their cities names. e.g. Newfoundland ~ HMCS St. Johns, Nova Scotia ~ HMCS Halifax, Prince Edward Island ~ HMCS Charlottetown, New Brunswick ~ HMCS Fredricton, Manitoba ~ HMCS Winnipeg, Saskatchewan ~ HMCS Regina, Alberta ~ HMCS Calgary and.......Quebec ~ HMCS Ville de Quebec. (Dont know what happened to the territories!)

It came to pass that this might be be seen as a major affront to la belle province therefore HMCS Victoria became........voila! HMCS Montreal!!! After all Ontario and B.C. had two...and that would never do!

Victoria as a provincial capitol had to be resolved somehow! Eurika! new submarines! Lets call them the "Victoria" class and name the lead boat Victoria, problem solved. Now we can't get into the same situation with the submarines as we did with the frigates so we will name them after ports on the extremes of the cardinal points of the compass.

Victoria is certainly west, Windsor is certainly south, Cornerbrook is certainly east and Chicoutimi is certainly north, well a little, sort of.
 

 

George Sullivan
 
Send comments to

The Editor

SAOC Website

 

   Return to Top                                                                      Return to Main Menu